In an age in which women’s reproductive rights are increasingly under attack, a minister and ethicist offers a stirring argument that abortion can be a moral good
Here’s a fact that we often ignore: unplanned pregnancy and abortion are a normal part of women’s reproductive lives. Roughly one-third of US women will have an abortion by age forty-five, and fifty to sixty percent of the women who have abortions were using birth control during the month they got pregnant. Yet women who have abortions are routinely shamed and judged, and safe and affordable access to abortion is under relentless assault, with the most devastating impact on poor women and women of color.
Rebecca Todd Peters, a Presbyterian minister and social ethicist, argues that this shaming and judging reflects deep, often unspoken patriarchal and racist assumptions about women and women’s sexual activity. These assumptions are at the heart of what she calls the justification framework, which governs our public debate about abortion, and disrupts our ability to have authentic public discussions about the health and well-being of women and their families.
Abortion, then, isn’t the social problem we should be focusing on. The problem is our inability to trust women to act as rational, capable, responsible moral agents who must weigh the concrete moral question of what to do when they are pregnant or when there are problems during a pregnancy.
Ambitious in method and scope, Trust Women skillfully interweaves political analysis, sociology, ancient and modern philosophy, Christian tradition, and medical history, and grounds its analysis in the material reality of women’s lives and their decisions about sexuality, abortion, and child-bearing. It ends with a powerful re-imagining of the moral contours of pre-natal life and suggests we recognize pregnancy as a time when a woman must assent, again and again, to an ethical relationship with the prenate.
“A courageous, personal book. . . This theologically astute and social justice–minded book will appeal to progressive Christians who are interested in reclaiming abortion as an issue of women’s health and could easily become part of the required reading for an array of university courses.”
—Publishers Weekly, Starred Review
“Offers a compelling case for radically revising the way we think and speak about women’s reproductive experience. . . . While written specifically for Christians, this will be a valuable read for anyone who questions the pronatalism and misogyny that constrains reproductive decision-making in the United States and seeks to shift our public debate in a more just direction.”
—Library Journal, Starred Review
“[Trust Women] will pave the way for more accounts that connect faith and reproductive justice, but it also shows how hard it is to escape the access focus of reproductive rights.”
—Rewire News
“In Trust Women, Rebecca Todd Peters lays bare the real question underlying the abortion debate: whether or not women can be trusted to make their own decisions. She is compassionate and clear-eyed in constructing her faith-based case for abortion, and her voice cuts through the noise to affirm what we at Planned Parenthood have long believed: the best arbiter of a woman’s reproductive destiny is herself.”
—Cecile Richards, president of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America and president of the Planned Parenthood Action Fund
“Rebecca Todd Peters pivots away from Christian fatalism about women and sex, baked-in misogyny about women’s morality, and patriarchal legislation controlling women’s bodies. Creating new language and new ethical theory, she applies an intersectional reproductive justice framework to persuasively argue that reframing abortion as a moral good for women begins with trusting women to be moral decision makers.”
—Loretta Ross, co-editor of Radical Reproductive Justice and co-founder of SisterSong Women of Color Reproductive Justice Collective
“Peters offers us the moral conversation for which we have been waiting. Instead of the polarizing and ahistorical Christian perspective that you have come to expect on this topic, be prepared to read something that makes you think through a deeply nuanced and unflinchingly personal lens about abortion, motherhood, and justice.”
—Traci C. West, author of Disruptive Christian Ethics: When Racism and Women’s Lives Matter
“Dr. Peters exposes the unethical framework that for years has been the foundation of antiabortion politics and policies. Highlighting the systemic devaluation and marginalization of women, especially those of color and who are poor, Peters’ work exposes the hypocrisy of the religio-legislative narrative of abortion as attacks against the most vulnerable. This is an important book for physicians, clergy, legislators, justice advocates, and those who seek to understand critical debates about life!”
—Rev. Dr. Cari Jackson, Religious Coalition for Reproductive Choice
“Rebecca Todd Peters, in a creative, elegant, and timely move, changes the Christian ethical question from the morality of abortion to the morality of choosing motherhood. She exchanges a justification model for one steeped in reproductive justice so women’s many choices can be respected.”
—Mary E. Hunt, co-founder and co-director of the Women’s Alliance for Theology, Ethics, and Ritual (WATER)
INTRODUCTION
ONE IN THREE
CHAPTER 1
You Shouldn’t Have a Baby Just Because You’re Pregnant
CHAPTER 2
Abortion in Real Life
CHAPTER 3
Abortion Policy as the Public Abuse of Women
WHY MISOGYNY AND PATRIARCHY MATTER
CHAPTER 4
Misogyny Is Exhausting
CHAPTER 5
Patriarchy as Social Control
CHAPTER 6
The Tragedy of Flawed Moral Discourse
MOVING FROM JUSTIFICATION TO JUSTICE
CHAPTER 7
Reimagining Pregnancy
CHAPTER 8
Motherhood as Moral Choice
CHAPTER 9
Celebrating the Moral Courage of Women
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS
NOTES
INDEX
- “Rebecca Todd Peters is on a mission to get churches to talk about abortion,” Religion News Service, article feature
- “Our Supremely Regressive Court of the Unsettled States: A Resister’s Reading List, ” Beacon Broadside, blog
- “Religions don't agree on abortion. That's why some faiths plan to take their case to court.” USA Today, Rebecca Todd Peters quoted in report
- “How the Supreme Court recalibrated the abortion debate in just 3 words,” CNN, Trust Women quoted in report
- “Is Abortion Sacred?” The New Yorker, Rebecca Todd Peters quoted in essay
- “Abortion Bans Are Against My Religion,” Rewire News Group, article
- “Channeling shock, rage and disbelief post-Roe,” Faith & Leadership, article
- “The 12 Books You Need to Read Post the Supreme Court’s Roe v. Wade Smackdown,” Oprah Daily, included in post-Roe book round-up
- “Trusting women to make abortion decisions is a Christian norm,” The News & Observer, op-ed
- “WATER Recommends: May 2018,” WATER (Women’s Alliance for Theology, Ethics, and Ritual), listed in reading roundup
- “Critics and Activists Add Ferment to Religion Publishing,” Publishers Weekly, write-up included in religion/spirituality feature
- “A Christian Argument for Abortion,” The Nation, Q&A
- “Beyond Abortion: Why Rebecca Todd Peters Wrote ‘Trust Women,’” Publishers Weekly, Q&A
- “Religion and Spirituality Books Preview: April 2018,” Publishers Weekly, included in April book preview
- Life News, book announcement, 2/23/2018
- Book Riot, listed in “24 Amazing New Feminist Books Coming in 2018” reading roundup, 12/19/2017