The first biography to unearth the fascinating relationship between Anne Sullivan Macy and Helen Keller
After many years, historian and Helen Keller expert Kim Nielsen realized that she, along with other historians and biographers, had failed Anne Sullivan Macy. While Macy is remembered primarily as Helen Keller’s teacher and mythologized as a straightforward educational superhero, the real story of this brilliant, complex, and misunderstood woman, who described herself as a “badly constructed human being,” has never been completely told.
Beyond the Miracle Worker, the first biography of Macy in nearly fifty years, complicates the typical Helen-Annie “feel good” narrative in surprising ways. By telling the life from Macy’s perspective-not Keller’s-the biography is the first to put Macy squarely at the center of the story. It presents a new and fascinating tale about a wounded but determined woman and her quest for a successful, meaningful life.
Born in 1866 to poverty-stricken Irish immigrants, the parentless and deserted Macy suffered part of her childhood in the Massachusetts State Almshouse at Tewksbury. Seeking escape, in love with literature, and profoundly stubborn, she successfully fought to gain an education at the Perkins School for the Blind.
As an adult, Macy taught Keller, helping the girl realize her immense potential, and Macy’s intimate friendship with Keller remained powerful throughout their lives. Yet as Macy floundered with her own blindness, ill health, and depression, as well as a tumultuous and triangulated marriage, she came to lean on her former student, emotionally, physically, and economically.
Based on privately held primary source material, including materials at both the American Foundation for the Blind and the Perkins School for the Blind, Beyond the Miracle Worker is revelatory and absorbing, unraveling one of the best known-and least understood-friendships of the twentieth century.
“Fascinating and beautifully crafted, Beyond the Miracle Worker reinterprets Macy’s life, challenging the mythology of her work with Helen Keller to reveal a powerful, rich, and surprising personal story. . . . Conveying the complexity and humanity of Macy and her world, this is an appealing biography for general readers and scholars alike.” —Susan Burch author of Signs of Resistance: American Deaf Community History, 1900 to World War II
“How remarkable it is to learn about the complicated, flesh-and-blood person behind the feisty legend at the water pump. Kim Nielsen’s biography reveals so much about one of the greatest teachers of all time, and her compassionate and honest writing made my heart go out to Annie Sullivan.” —Rachel Simon, author of Riding The Bus With My Sister
“Rejecting hagiography, Nielsen offers a complex portrait of the woman Helen Keller called ‘Teacher.’ Especially interesting are Nielsen’s reflections on Sullivan’s own vision impairment and her lifelong struggle to support herself. It’s time we all move beyond the sentimental trope of the ‘miracle worker’ as we consider the actual predicaments of those who care for and instruct people with disabilities.”BR>
—Ralph James Savarese, author of Reasonable People: A Memoir of Autism and Adoption
“Kim Nielsen’s absorbing biography of Anne Sullivan Macy not only captures the complexity of Sullivan’s character, but also offers fresh insights into her relationship with her famous pupil. Thoroughly researched, persuasive, and readable, Beyond the Miracle Worker is both a compelling story and an important contribution to women’s history and the history of the disabled.” —Elisabeth Gitter, author of The Imprisoned Guest: Samuel Howe and Laura Bridgman, the Original Deaf-Blind Girl
“Nielsen’s engaging and comprehensive account of Annie Sullivan reveals a woman of great intellect and complexity who overcame many challenges in her own right. This book will irrevocably change what you thought you knew about the ‘Helen-Annie’ story.” —Judith Heumann, Disability Rights Advocate and former U.S. Assistant Secretary Department of Education
“This is a remarkable story of a vulnerable woman in a culture that allowed women neither freedom nor power. Still, somehow Anne, an almost blind orphan living in a poorhouse, managed to secure an education and carve out an independent life for herself and her student, Helen Keller. Anne Sullivan Macy is a feminist hero and this fine book teaches us that.” —Mary Pipher, author of Seeking Peace: Chronicles of the Worst Buddhist in the World
Review: Feminist Review - November 18, 2009
“Nielsen has written a very humanizing story . . .”
Review: America Magazine - November 9, 2009
“Kim Nielsen’s engaging and excellently researched new biography of Anne Sullivan Macy and her relationship with Helen Keller reveals unknown shadows and contradictory facets of their lives.”
Review: Women's Review of Books - November 1, 2009
“Now, in Beyond the Miracle Worker, Nielsen further revises the Keller-Sullivan narrative by placing the teacher at center stage. She portrays Sullivan Macy as a complex, deeply troubled woman who needed Helen Keller at least as much as Keller needed her…Drawing lavishly upon letters, diaries, and other primary sources, Nielsen conveys the rich texture of Sullivan’s character.”
Review: Disability Studies Quarterly - August 1, 2009
“Kim Nielsen overcomes all the obstacles her recalcitrant subject throws in her path, and creates a portrait of Sullivan's life that is complex with all its contradictions and inconsistencies. Beyond the Miracle Worker also serves as an example to other historians of disability to mine the records of institutions like Tewksbury for other untold stories of disabled lives. Even while Sullivan's was a singular life, Nielsen puts it in the context of nineteenth and early twentieth century American culture, highlighting the intricate interplay between gender, class and disability that shaped it.”
Review: The Daily Sound - June 16, 2009
“Exhaustively researched and not always complimentary, Beyond the Miracle Worker goes way beyond all the stuff you read in school about the complicated, headstrong woman who gave Helen Keller words…Using documents and diaries, author Kim E. Nielsen offers the sometimes heartbreaking, often frustrating life and work of Anne Sullivan Macy… If a biography is on your reading to-do list this summer, Beyond the Miracle Worker is a worthy one for you. Grab this book and learn a thing or two.”
Review: Publisher's Weekly - March 2, 2009
“After writing two books about Helen Keller, historian Nielsen (The Radical Lives of Helen Keller) vowed she ‘would never again write anything even remotely related to her.’ Fortunately, she couldn't help herself.”
Review by: Carol Haggas, Booklist - March 1, 2009
“Historian Nielsen focuses attention on Macy’s troubled beginnings, her own devastating eye ailments, and her prodigious ambition to create a considerate yet equitable biography of a complex woman whose singular contributions to the burgeoning field of education for the blind have often been misjudged.”
Review: Library Journal - March 1, 2009
“…succeeds admirably….Macy’s complexity is revealed…essential reading for those interested in Macy or Keller.”
It’s temp ting to begin this book like a fairy tale. Once upon a time a poor, blind, and orphaned child named Annie magically grew into a happy, sighted, and successful adult woman. She became a miracle worker, lighting the intellectual fire and imagination of the deaf-blind girl Helen Keller at a water pump in the wilds of Alabama. We know this kind of story. Many of our books and movies, the morality tales and parables we tell, even the heroes we’ve created, are versions of the same inspirational tale. The cheerful and uplifting message is that yes, you too can conquer anything in order to do the impossible.
But I won’t.
“Any book about me,” Anne Sullivan Macy reflected near the end of her life, “must be full of contradictions.”1 Beyond the Miracle Worker is a book that reflects these contradictions--the contradictions of a delightful, gloomy, charismatically fascinating, and annoying woman who was neither blind nor sighted. Though she was born in 1866, her life is a surprisingly contemporary tale. It is the story of a caring, fiercely proud, and intelligent woman trying to forge meaningful human relationships despite her own ingrained flaws and wounds. It is the story of a woman deeply frightened of depending upon anyone else for emotional, economic, or social sustenance.
And yet--in one of those contradictions that Macy warned us about--she made one notable exception: she did not hesitate to lean on her famous student, and later friend, Helen Keller. While the whole world assumed that Keller’s deaf-blindness forced her to depend on her teacher, Anne Sullivan Macy, my research suggests that the reverse more accurately characterizes their relationship of nearly fifty years. Macy leaned on Keller, juggling her uneasy combination of emotional vulnerability and a fierce desire for independence. Her lifelong struggle with chronic illness and depression was far more debilitating than Keller’s deaf-blindness. Keller provided love, acceptance, daily assistance, an income, and a home. Their deep friendship, and Macy’s willingness to allow herself to be dependent on Keller, gave meaning to Macy’s life. Macy regarded herself as a “badly constructed human being,” perceptively providing a way to understand the complex adult that the orphaned and deserted child of the Tewksbury Almshouse became. Yet, we shouldn’t confine her to that characterization. As she herself admitted, “some of us blunder into life through the back door.”
Though it may have been through the back door, and blunder she did, she entered into life fully.
Indeed, she saw the benefits of blundering, and faltering through life didn’t bother her. “If all people knew what was good for them and acted accordingly, this world would be a different world, though not nearly so interesting. But we don’t know what’s good for us, and I’m spending my days in experimenting. The experiments are amusing--and sometimes costly, but there’s no other way of getting knowledge.”
This remark characterizes Anne Sullivan Macy perhaps better than anything else. From childhood on, many others had held firm opinions about what was good for her. Those opinions could amuse her, wound her, or strengthen her, but in the end her determination to discover her own life path lay at the very core of her character. She knew she had made mistakes--some of them profoundly painful. Whatever the benefit, whatever the cost, she had to discover for herself what was best. The marvel is the ferocity with which she thirsted to discover life, in its pains and its joys, for herself. As she said in concluding one of her 1916 letters to Helen, “We have only to keep a stiff upper lip and do our damnedest.”
After comp leting two previous books on Helen Keller I swore I would never again write anything even remotely related to her. I started a project far removed from Keller. I informed everyone in my professional circle about that far-removed project in order to commit myself to it.
Then I reread Anne Sullivan Macy’s 1916 letters to Helen Keller. Macy had written them as she dealt with the illness that she thought would kill her. The letters reveal an introspective woman trying to understand her life. Vacillating between urgency and detachment, she reflected on pleasure, anger, complacency, and amazement. It struck me that her life embodied both contradictions and intensity: physical pain, emotional pain, isolation, friendship, joy, intellect, tenacity, success, and near constant self-doubt. Yet, as she thought about death, as she pondered her life, she took immense joy in the daily life of the Puerto Rican countryside where she was staying.
As I reconsidered Macy, I became convinced that I, and nearly everyone else, had shortchanged the woman known only as the teacher of Helen Keller. A new biography of Anne Sullivan Macy is greatly needed, not only to do justice to her and to provide a peephole into Keller and Macy’s multifaceted, and often surprising, friendship, but also because our cultural memory mythologizes and simplifies Macy as a straightforward educational superhero. She deserves more. In addition, the increasing but still slow integration of people with disabilities into education, the workplace, and the public world makes this project significant. Macy’s disability did not occur in a vacuum, isolated and abstract. Her daily experience of it was often defined by context--by institutions, by the expectations of others, and by the lack of social welfare support. Her life story, particularly when placed alongside that of Keller, reminds us of the diversity of disability experiences historically and today--and of the multiple ways that we, as individuals, as institutions, and as a country, contribute to the disabling nature of physical and mental impairments.
Surprisingly, telling the life story of Anne Sullivan Macy with her as the central figure is a markedly new strategy. Numerous Keller biographies, both older and more recent, discuss Macy but primarily as an ancillary figure to the real star of the story. These include Joseph P. Lash’s Helen and Teacher: The Story of Helen Keller and Anne Sullivan Macy (1980) and Dorothy Herrmann’s Helen Keller: A Life (1998). Helen and Teacher provides the most complex analysis of Macy but retains a nearly exclusive focus on her development and life as a teacher. The most comprehensive biography of Macy is that of Nella Braddy Henney, Anne Sullivan Macy: The Story Behind Helen Keller (1933). Endorsed by Keller, approved by Macy, and written by an intimate friend of both women, this book sought to establish Macy as a pedagogical hero. Macy’s most recent adult biography, published over forty years ago by Lorena Hickok, also defines her only according to Keller--even in its title: The Touch of Magic: The Story of Helen Keller’s Great Teacher, Anne Sullivan Macy (1961). Macy was Keller’s teacher, and proud of it, but her life story is so much more complicated and interesting than that single-minded characterization.
The goal of Beyond the Miracle Worker is to present Anne Sullivan Macy in all of her complexity. First and foremost, by telling and analyzing Macy’s life as her story--not Helen’s--this biography tells a new tale. Beyond the Miracle Worker follows the accidental and unexpected path an orphaned asylum child took to become a world-famous educator. This includes an intimate depiction of growing up amidst the horrors of a mid-nineteenth-century asylum, a rarely if ever told story in U.S. history. It chronicles a tumultuous marriage. It analyzes the adult life of a chronically ill, disabled woman whose public identity excluded nearly all acknowledgment of her disability. It follows a smart and ambitious woman trying to make a professional life in a patriarchal society. And it traces the ever-changing friendship between Macy and Keller, in which the deaf-blind Keller eventually cared for and became the personal aid of her former teacher.
In many ways, Macy resembles an archetypal American figure--the self-made man. As a young orphan housed in Massachusetts’s Tewksbury Almshouse, she pleaded her way out with single-minded determination by literally pulling on the sleeves of touring philanthropists and begging for an education. Later on in her life, she exercised further determination and retained control of the child Helen Keller--and thus of her own professional life--despite the machinations of numerous others who were far more powerful. With intense purposefulness, she repeatedly created herself. The obvious complication, however, is that though a “self-made man,” she was female, disabled, and of (to her) shameful beginnings. Her life raises questions about the opportunities available to women to reinvent themselves in turn-of-the-century America.
A related theme is that of the narrow but changing economic and professional opportunities available to women. Macy is contemporary with the first generation of female college students who embraced pivotal and important roles in U.S. social reform, education, and civic life. She is a contemporary of those who--like Jane Addams, Julia Lathrop, and Florence Kelley--developed and energized the settlement house movement. She is, however, dramatically different. Though an extremely brilliant woman, she lacked any educational training or advanced degree, came from a family with no connections to wealth or prestige, was deeply ashamed of her past, and had little involvement in broad social reform. Other than her relationship to Keller, she had few opportunities to build on for personal advancement. Those she had came from flirtatious relationships with older men. From the time of Keller’s college graduation in 1904 until the early 1920s the two constantly sought new economic opportunities and stability as various money-making attempts failed. While she and Keller clearly valued one another, Macy clung to the relationship with such tenacity partially because of the narrow options available for a woman of her class and background, let alone one with a disability.
Also important to this biography and Macy’s life is the theme of education. As a child, Macy grasped for an education as an escape, and a redemption, from poverty and the almshouse. As an untrained, inexperienced, and isolated young woman she accomplished a task many had thought impossible: teaching language to the almost sevenyear- old deaf-blind Helen Keller. Though not a Radcliffe student, she attended the prestigious female college alongside Keller, fingerspelling for her all lectures and books. Ironically, the woman who became one of the world’s most famous educators had no educational training, and did little regarding the education of others after her one student became an adult.
- Read Kim Nielsen's op-ed piece for the History News Network
- Click here to read a review of Nielsen's work in the Journal of American History